Average customer rating:
|
The Deviant's Advantage: How Fringe Ideas Create Mass Markets
Ryan Mathews , and Watts Wacker Manufacturer: Crown Business ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover Similar Items:
ASIN: 0609609580 Release Date: 2002-09-10 |
Book Description
Don’t consider yourself deviant? Well, that just may be a career breaker. Odds are the idea or product that will transform your business or industry tomorrow is out there right now, hiding in the shadows of the Fringe, raw, messy, untamed, and just waiting to be exploited. Trapping, taming, and marketing it is the key to burying your competition and staying ahead of your market.Customer Reviews:
A Great Motivator for Creatives.......2006-10-26
Somewhat interesting, but weak thesis and sloppy editing.......2004-05-07
This book distracted be because of dozens of factual errors, from people, to products, to ideas. The errors range from small, like getting the name of the Cue:Cat bar-code scanner wrong, to major errors, like stating in several places that the book of "Genesis" starts with "In the beginning was the word". (Of course, this is how the Christian bible begins, and is not in the Jewish book of Genesis/B'reishet.) I tried to contact the authors directly about these errors, but they didn't answer my mail.
Given the poor editing, it makes me wonder about the rest of his conclusions. For example he suggests that Kodak reinvent itself by becoming the world's photo storage solution. It'll be easy for Mr. Wacker and Mr. Mathews to say in a few years---when Kodak gets in further trouble--See! You should have listened to me!
This book was an entertaining read, but really just a rehash of the old-dot-com "Viral Marketing/Let's shake things up" philosophy that died with the dotcoms. I didn't learn anything new about marketing, and the only thing I learned about punditry is I need a cool name like "Watts Wacker" to let people listen to *my* wacky ideas!
From Oddity to Conventional Wisdom to Obscurity.......2003-09-15
The authors are usually speaking about deviants and deviance in the positive sense of "something or someone operating in a defined measure away from the norm." In our quest for the "new" and "authentic," such deviances sometimes attract a wider audience. In the process of attracting that audience, the deviance is "cleaned" up to be acceptable to a broader group of people until a majority find it appealing . . . at least until the novelty wears off or something more "authentic" shows up.
To understand this process, readers will probably benefit from also reading The Tipping Point and The Anatomy of Buzz.
The authors go on to point out why this process operates more rapidly than in the past. They primarily focus on language becoming more ambiguous, science making reality less objective, and the impact of a more visually stimulated culture. The point about language is particularly well done.
Finally, the authors look at how corporations, those models of conformity, can incorporate deviance by becoming aware of it and incorporating more external perspectives. Hire differently, get new stakeholders involved, and use creative brainstorming techniques to look for potentially more valuable core competencies). This last section is filled with examples of the authors' consulting experiences with major corporations. They end up with an entertaining use of social archetypes to discuss how to disseminate ideas (trickster, clown, wizard, shaman, seer, provocateur, fool).
The authors are unusually well read and very into the latest "new, new" thing. As a result, they make many allusions that are constructive and interesting for their case.
The book does, however, (as my 3 star rating suggests) have substantial weaknesses.
First, the prose is often hard to comprehend due to allusions that are incomplete. This is the fourth sentence in the introduction. "Our simple answer is that deviance happened, and our simple bet is that the barbarians haven't even begun to party." To make matters worse, the authors like to add new terms to spice things up (devox -- "the voice, spirit, or incarnation of deviant ideas, products, and individuals"). When these terms are applied, meaning can become obscure. "Deviants seek out other deviants -- this is how 'scenes' are formed and 'scenes' eventually birth markets. The neotribe . . . ."
Second, the authors claim too much for their point. "Innovation -- all innovation, positive and negative -- begins as a deviant idea germinating in the mind of a person dwelling on the Fringe of society." You can translate that into someone who is not an average person with average behavior thought of it first. Does that amaze you? Almost no one is an average person with average behavior. Further, the importance of major innovations (such as electronics, biotechnology, new sources of energy) comes from developing concepts into reality. What difference does it make who thought of these concepts first? If you look at the important, lasting innovations, these were mostly developed within some large organization (Bell Labs for the transistor, major universities for biotechnology, Boeing for modern jet transportation and so on). Yes, the early conceptualization started with a few individuals . . . but until we develop a Borg-like mind that will happen by definition. Most of what the authors are talking about are "trendy" happenings in social situations. Even those trendy new things are often stimulated by major companies (for example, most of those trendy drinks mentioned in the book start out in the market research departments of some liquor company . . . and are then seeded into trendy bars with corporate promotional efforts). In other words, the authors are ascribing behavior to everything that only applies to some things.
Third, the authors also draw unnecessarily on shock value. Early on there is a detailed description of how HBO portrayed the new torture chic (involving intimate parts of the anatomy). How is that a positive deviation?
Fourth, in describing the application to businesses over a third of the material comes across sounding like an ad for their consulting services. That wouldn't be so bad, except that the examples mostly seem to be ones that the companies didn't use very long . . . or never started with. Those examples don't even seem to add credibility to the process.
Fifth, the authors are very interested in businesses creating new business models, usually through focusing on a new core insight into what will reward stakeholders (customers, end users, employees, shareholders, lenders, distributors, partners, etc.). But they make almost no attempt as to how to take the new core insight and apply it into making a new business model for that organization. In other words, the hard part is left out. That is surprising, because the authors describe many continuing business model innovators like Richard Branson, Dell Computer, Red Hat, and Harley-Davidson. Most companies will need a lot more guidance than this book provides for how to apply these lessons.
Ultimately, the book seems flawed more by a lack of editing than anything else. It's almost as though the editors did not have the right knowledge of business and organizations to make the material both comprehensible and relevant.
After you finish this interesting book, I suggest that you think about how you can listen more carefully to what those who are different from you are saying. Who are you ignoring now? How can you start understanding them better? If you do those things, this book will be a winner for you.
Embrace Risk.......2003-07-22
What I love about this book is that while it makes a strong case for the importance of deviant thinking in the world of business, it simultaneously explains why so little exists there, and how unlikely it is to ever appear in great abundance. It's just not the way most of the people in the corporate world have been conditioned to behave. Despite all the exhortations to "think out of the box", the vast majority of executives are simply out of their element anywhere else but inside one.
However, as the authors deconstruct the emergence of new and valuable ideas, those things destined to become the next "new" thing, they offers many pointers on how to identify these developing trends before they become mainstream. In so doing, they also coin an especially inelegant term for the originators of these ideas, the "devox" is what they call them. But this is a minor blemish on what is otherwise a truly important book. At the end of the day, what the authors argue brilliantly and illustrate repeatedly is that businesses that embrace risk may be far safer than those that avoid it.
beware consultants gushing over their patrons........2003-07-02
I got through about 50 or so pages when I realized that life was too short. Interesting how the great geniuses of our time can't seem to cover the basics. Here's a clue-- everyone has wacky ideas-- they're written down on cocktail napkins everywhere. "Thinking out of the box" and all of its related concepts contributes to success about as much as regular bowel movements. Just once, I'd like to see someone write about "committment to follow through" or "excellence in implementation", but I suppose such ideas are too vulgar to be considered by high thinkers.
Average customer rating:
|
Cato Supreme Court Review, 2004-2005 (Cato Supreme Court Review)
Mark K. Moller Manufacturer: Cato Institute ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 1930865805 |
Book Description
In this annual review, leading consitutional scholars offer a timely analysis of the most important cases from Supreme Court's 2004-2005 term from classical Madisonian perspective.Customer Reviews:
Outstanding analysis with the classical liberal perspective.......2006-11-30
Essential Reading.......2005-12-30
Average customer rating:
|
How We Got Here: A Slightly Irreverent History of Technology and Markets
Andy Kessler Manufacturer: Collins ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0060840978 Release Date: 2005-06-14 |
Book Description
Best–selling author Andy Kessler ties up the loose ends from his provocative book, Running Money, with this history of breakthrough technology and the markets that funded them.
Expanding on themes first raised in his tour de force, Running Money, Andy Kessler unpacks the entire history of Silicon Valley and Wall Street, from the Industrial Revolution to computers, communications, money, gold and stock markets. These stories cut (by an unscrupulous editor) from the original manuscript were intended as a primer on the ways in which new technologies develop from unprofitable curiosities to essential investments. Indeed, How We Got Here is the book Kessler wishes someone had handed him on his first day as a freshman engineering student at Cornell or on the day he started on Wall Street. This book connects the dots through history to how we got to where we are today.
Customer Reviews:
Great Book.......2007-02-21
mildly entertaining.......2006-07-29
Fun, light reading for a sunday long bus ride...........2006-06-26
Fun and Important Book.......2006-01-02
Not what I expected. I love his first two books much more.......2005-12-02
Average customer rating: |
Markets for Technology: The Economics of Innovation and Corporate Strategy
Ashish Arora , Andrea Fosfuri , and Alfonso Gambardella Manufacturer: The MIT Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0262511819 |
Book Description
The past two decades have seen a gradual but noticeable change in the economic organization of innovative activity. Most firms used to integrate research and development with activities such as production, marketing, and distribution. Today, firms are forming joint ventures, research and development alliances, licensing deals, and a variety of other outsourcing arrangements with universities, technology-based start-ups, and other established firms. In many industries, a division of innovative labor is emerging, with a substantial increase in the licensing of existing and prospective technologies. In short, technology and knowledge are becoming definable and tradable commodities.
Average customer rating:
|
Evolution Not Revolution: Aligning Technology with Corporate Strategy to Increase Market Valuation
John Logan Manufacturer: McGraw-Hill ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: 0071384103 |
Amazon.com
The day when information system leaders and business executives could function blissfully in their own isolated worlds is long gone--if indeed it ever really existed. John R. Logan's Evolution Not Revolution emphasizes why such professionals must now work closely together and outlines a series of six related competencies to help them do it. Logan, founder and CEO of the Aberdeen Group consulting company, says separation between these managers winds up producing a negative drag on performance that could be eliminated by introducing "a common set of management goals and principles for both to follow." Hinging everything on an overall corporate-wide information-age executive skill he dubs "emagineering," Logan spells out his approach to planning, deploying, operating, and measuring the advanced technological steps that spring from his suggested core proficiencies: fulfill the public's shifting demands, forge ties with existing customers and attract new ones, develop a common vision with business partners, maximize economic returns, execute functions on-time throughout the organization, and introduce technical operations necessary for a secure and flexible information system. "Connect the known, the suspected, and the new together," he writes, "and you will surely have the next great idea for improving the value of your company." --Howard RothmanBook Description
Arms executives with the management skills to combine excellent strategy with flawless execution
John Logan, the visionary founder of the prestigious Aberdeen Group consulting firm, has never been one to run from a battle. In his strategic call to arms Evolution Not Revolution, Logan challenges executives and managers to stop regarding IT as just another overhead cost, and instead use IT a powerful tool to create and execute superior strategies. He introduces six competencies, designed to close the gap between a company's business and technology management functions, grow revenue for the companyand ultimately increase its market valuation.
Logan's disarmingly simple yet ingeniously interconnected six competencies will help readers develop:
Customer Reviews:
Outdated.......2005-04-21
Review: Weak Content/Could Have Been Useful 5 Years Ago.......2004-07-05
I think Logan has done a decent job of outlining some IT adoption problems in corporations. Like some of the other reviewers have said, however, the book is simply not useful for large corporatations. It seems like Logan has always been a consultant. Never appreciating the politics and bureaucracy the IT department has to go through to implement new IT initiatives.
These guys like Logan come in with pie in the sky dreams. Fact of the matter is, we IT executives need to focus on getting maximum benefit out of minimum capital. The book simply expects too much. Dreaming.
Maybe business execs could read the book and get more out of it. But Logan is a soporiphic writer. I stopped used sleeping pills. All I needed to do was read a chapter of this book and I'd sleep well:)
Logan's problem is that he is writing a book for IT execs that he should be writing for business executives. He should have written the book with more succinct sentences. He should have cut the book in half at least.
Business guys don't like technology for the most part. To get them to pick up a boring and long book to teach them how to use IT is impossible.
That is the main problem with Logan's stuff -- ok content, terribly written, geared for the wrong audience, and pie in the sky dreams.
Overall, I would not recommend reading this book, unless you are having problems sleeping.
Maybe it would have been pertinent if I had actually gotten around to reading it when it was sent to me. The fact of the matter is that the book is now outdated.
Pass.......2004-04-28
First chapter, good. Then the book got worse and worse. Clearly, the author has never worked in a large organization. He has no idea the difficulties facing CIOs in large and small companies. So while Login's ideas are ok, they have no benefit in the real corporate world in America.
But the book is not academic enough (i.e. good enough) for universities to use this.
I would NOT recommend this book. It is another one of those non-acadmemic, non-thought provoking books that just is not grounded in reality.
Fake Reviews/OK Book.......2004-04-05
That is not right. Amazon should do something about this to ensure the integrity of these reviews.
Anyhoo, this book is decent. I'd recommend this book to mid-level managers in big firms who went to college after the tech revolution. Might have good insights for you.
But for a small firm these ideas dont work. And if you already are even broderline tech savvy, this book is not good. Basically just rehashes what everyone already knows.
If this book were written in the mid90s i would have recommended it to more people. But frankly, it is outdated now. This book came out a decade late.
I give it two stars. not horrible but not worht the money.
Dubious Reviews.......2004-03-22
Logan's book has some decent insights. Heck, he is right, more business and IT execs have to work together. Too many IT ventures fail.
But the book is terribly boring, even for a techie as an author.
The editor should have made the writing better.
I might give 2 stars to this, but those previous 3 reviews were soooo fake, I gotta give it 1 star to counterbalance those fake reviews.
Average customer rating: |
Markets for Technology - The Economics of Innovation and Corporate Strategy
A Arora Manufacturer: The MIT Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000OQ6R9S |
Average customer rating: |
Markets for Technology - The Economics of Innovation and Corporate Strategy
A Arora Manufacturer: The MIT Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000OQD0V6 |
Books:
Recommended Books