Average customer rating:
|
The Groves of Academe
Mary McCarthy Manufacturer: Harvest Books ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0156027879 |
Book Description
Customer Reviews:
Ambitious & Profound.......2004-05-27
¡°Teaching, like all the arts, can¡¯t be democratic or subject to referendum; it must be run from within, by an autonomous guild, according to guild standards.¡±¡Now what are these standards to be? Are they to be administrative or internal? Like the standards of a poem? Within certain limits, isn¡¯t it possible for each teacher to make his own, as a poem makes its own laws?...¡±But a poem¡justifies itself in the long run by referring back to life¡.¡± ¡ ¡°Somebody¡ªI believe Orwell¡ª¡says that you can¡¯t prove that a poem is good. A piece of news we must keep from the students at all cost or we should all be out of a job.¡± ¡°You can¡¯t prove that a poem is good, but you can know it,¡± said Domna, suddenly, with conviction¡ ¡°In general, we submit ourselves to the judgment of the poets in these matters; we allow our poets to tell us that Donne is superior to Milton, and here perhaps we are wrong, but we cannot know that we are wrong until we also become poets. Tolstoy was wrong, in my belief, about Shakespeare, but his wrongness has a certain authority; we pause to listen to him because he was a poet. In the same way, it is only we teachers who have earned the right to be listened to on the question of another teacher¡¯s competence, who have earned,¡± she finished, somewhat defiantly, ¡°the right, if you want, to be wrong.¡±
The argument can be read as a comment on the blacklisting of artists & intellectuals by Senator McCarthy. McCarthy (the author) however, is too much of an artist to present her indictment in simple terms. You see, Mulcahy, the hero/victim, is a thoroughly unwholesome character. A reader is hard pressed to sympathize with him as he goes about manipulating his colleagues to secure his stated goal of ¡° ¡®Justice for myself as a superior individual.¡¯¡± When Mulcahy voices this appraisal, the reader has seen enough of his disregard for other people to doubt his sanity. Even so, Mulcahy has his virtues. And in professor Bentkoop¡¯s view, they make him a valuable asset to the faculty.
Quote:
¡°There¡¯s a good deal to be said for Hen on the plus side¡He¡¯s interested in ontological questions, which are the great binders of diverse humanity¡What¡¯s needed at Jocelyn or any college is a mind concerned with universals and first principles; the students take to them like catnip if they¡¯re given half a chance¡A student reads an author for his ideas, for his personal metaphysic, what he calls, till you people teach him not to say it, his ¡®philosophy of life.¡¯ He wants to detach from an author a portable philosophy.¡±
I don't think McCarthy would write that if she didn't want a reader to approach her book from that angle. And for that matter, take the following:
Quote:
His talk was, in fact, so clear that the best disposal the Literature faculty could make of it was to assume that they had not understood it, that of the proverbial four levels of meaning that they so stringently enforced on their classes they themselves had seized only on the literal and had failed of the moral, the allegorical, and the anagogical.
There's a whole scene, in chiaroscuro, where Bentkoop & Domna work out the philosophical ramifications of Mulcahy's behavior. Here¡¯s the tail end of the conversation, throughout which, Domna attacks Mulcahy & Bentkoop apologizes for him.
Quote:
¡°This abrogation of judgment you practice is an insult to man¡¯s dignity. Everybody has the right to be judged and to judge in his turn. This ¡®understanding you accord Henry is dangerous, both to him and to you. God is our judge, you will tell me. But there is no God. God is man.¡± The blasphemous words rang out; the windows rattled; but John seemed unaffected. ¡°God is man, Domna, if you wish,¡± he said gravely. ¡°But He is not men.¡±
Domna suddenly looked tired. ¡°No,¡± she admitted. ¡°I suppose in a certain way I am on your side. If I presume to judge Henry, I don¡¯t presume to punish him. That is not my affair. She sighed. ¡°And yet I can¡¯t help but feel that I¡¯m implicated in a frightful swindle.¡±
This passage can be interpreted from a variety of angles. Morally, a middle ground between condemnation & forgiveness is reached. The ethical heart of the matter is located in the individual¡ªnot in any institutions, dogmas, or formulas. Any human being can judge another, precisely because of their shared humanity. The ¡°first principles¡± mentioned before are the basis for such judgments, not the formulations--political, intellectual, or religious¡ªof ¡°men.¡± The foremost of these principles is dignity. It¡¯s beneath the dignity of man (forgive the gender bias) to surrender the power of judgment to any outside force. But it is also beneath the dignity of man to punish the accused. The allegorical angle can be extracted painlessly. Between the McCarthyites on the one side & the Communists on the other, the dignity of the common man was hard pressed in the 1950¡¯s (as it is nowadays between the neocons & the fundamentalists) As for the anagogical angle, just replace the ¡°dignity of man¡± with ¡°God in man¡± and there you have it.
Not McCarthy's best..........2003-02-14
Flat and uninteresting.......2003-02-13
The setting in the post-war, commie witch-hunt days really turns out to be less important than anticipated. While it provides some interesting strategies for our anti-hero, it could be replaced with any number of "isms" without changing the essential effect.
McCarthy's style is excruciatingly dry and her dialogue is stilted to the point of being stylized. The sheer boredom of plowing through her prose deadens the mind to the point that any satirical effect is largely lost.
The jabs at "progressive" education were mildly entertaining, thus two stars rather than a mere one.
Language more literary than illuminating.......2002-01-01
Like Kingsley Amis' "Lucky Jim", a book I found to be absent much appeal, McCarthy offers a highly literate analysis of the travails of a male professor struggling at university after World War II. McCarthy's Henry Mulcahy is strapped by poverty, with a sickly wife and four children, in a temporary teaching position offered, in part, out of a sense of guilt by the college president. Then Mulcahy gets the dreaded and unexpected "non-renewal" letter.
Some aspects of academic life have not changed in fifty years: petty squabbles and politics, the longing for job security, the poor wages of some professors, the need for intrinsic interest in teaching, the complaints about students' habits. But the focus on communism and loyalty oaths as a basis for job insecurity is a distant memory to most people. And Mulcahy's own dishonesty (or grasp of reality) left me confused rather than sympathetic. Rather I found myself attuned to Mulcahy's nemesis, the president.
The story is simple yet the tone of the book put me off. There was more philosophy than conversation, and when academics did speak, they spoke in a fashion most would find hard to expect in conversation. I grew bored. The characters weren't that interesting despite their intelligence, and I found myself speed reading the last thirty pages. And I found myself as displeased with "Groves" as I had been with "Lucky Jim".
Sometimes very literate and well-educated authors don't translate well to my level, to meet my self-admittedly need for a clearer, more linear story and engaging characters.
lacks nuance.......2001-08-05
Average customer rating: |
Campus Architecture: Building in the Groves of Academe
Richard P. Dober Manufacturer: Mcgraw-Hill (Tx) ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: 0070171858 |
Book Description
Integrate campus architecture with sites and landscape. Discover the secrets of campus building and landscape planning with Richard P. Dober's Campus Atchitectulrde. Whether you're called upon to update and revitalize the existing architectural heritage of a campus, or design innovative new buildings that meet its present and future academic needs, this is the only guide you'll need. You'll find: how to incorporate computerized libraries, changing physical education and recreational needs, and new alternative campus housing designs; fully illustrated case studies of the best designs and redesigns; techniques for campus rehabilitation, repair, and renovation; how to meet environmental, conservation, and aesthetic considerations within the same project; how to provide long-term durability and operating economy within budget; and much m ore.
Average customer rating: |
The Groves of Academe
Manufacturer: Signet ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000F2XYAG |
Average customer rating: |
Academe
Paul Groves Manufacturer: Seren Books/Poetry Wales Pr Ltd ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: 0907476988 |
Average customer rating: |
FEMINIST SCHOLARSHIP: Kindling in the Groves of Academe
Ellen Carol Dubois Manufacturer: University of Illinois Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: 0252014642 |
Average customer rating: |
THE GROVES OF ACADEME
MARY MACARTHY Manufacturer: PANTHER BOOK ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000S7XW5K |
Average customer rating: |
The Groves of Academe
Mary McCarthy Manufacturer: Signet ProductGroup: Book Binding: Mass Market Paperback ASIN: B000K1WOBC |
Average customer rating: |
Groves of Academe
Mary McCarthy Manufacturer: HARCOURT, BRACE AND COMPANY ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: B000OKD22Y |
Average customer rating: |
The Groves of Academe
Mary McCarthy Manufacturer: Harcourt Brace & World ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: B000NYKM6K |
Average customer rating: |
The Groves of Academe
Mary McCarthy Manufacturer: Signet Books ProductGroup: Book Binding: Mass Market Paperback ASIN: B000OENWSO |
Average customer rating:
|
An Honorable Thief (Harlequin Historical, No. 616)
Anne Gracie Manufacturer: Harlequin ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0373292163 |
Customer Reviews:
Very enjoyable regency romance.......2006-09-13
I just don't get it!.......2004-04-23
Unexpected story from a great writer.......2002-09-02
We meet Kit Singleton, newly arrived in London for the season in 1816 - an heiress of some standing. At the same time there is a burglar sneaking into the houses of the wealthy - and Hugo Devenish meets this burglar unexpectedly. Unexpected on both sides when he is knocked down by this slight fellow - who sounded perculiarly Chinese.
Hugo suspects Miss Singleton is the key to the mystery and can't explain why. Miss Singleton isn't helping him, she has a sacred pact - vengeance she has sworn in her father's honour on his death-bed. There are no easy resolutions in this book but the action never seems contrived simply as plot devices.
The only quibble I have with Gracie's latest work is that the slang doesn't feel as Regency as it ought to and there are characters that seem more Victorian than Georgian - such as Sir William Marsden. I would have given this book 5 stars if it had been set in a Victorian setting for that reason. However one thing Gracie doesn't let us down on is a great story and that is definitely the most important thing!
Keeper for Regency fans!.......2002-07-04
I love romance novels with thieves and mistaken identities and I love my heroines daring, unique and on the wild side. Add to that some costly artefacts, jewels and a hero that is brooding, rich and unpretentious with no regard for society's strictures and you have a mix that I find irresistible.
The story is more complex than expected, surprising me with twists and turns without ever getting lost in them. I immensely enjoyed Ms. Gracie's style, not just for a story well told but for her choice of words that had me re-reading whole scenes just for the pleasure of it. It's never cute but witty, never pretentious but always vivid.
This is a true find and definitely a keeper especially for regency fans.
Fun and well-crafted.......2002-06-29
Kit Singleton arrives in London after a life spent in foreign parts with her father. She is charged with a mission to fulfill a deathbed promise she made to him. At the same time Hugo Devenish meets her and becomes curious about her past.
Anne Gracie skilfully weaves a quite complex story against the background of life amongst the ton of London. Kit and Hugo are unusual characters in this setting; both loners without normal family relationships who seem to swan in and out of society functions without really belonging. They are drawn together and I love the way Hugo is captivated by Kit without consciously recognising it. In my opinion an almost perfect hero. The side characters are well-drawn with lives of their own that add depth to the story.
Gracie’s writing style helps make her work so appealing to me. She uses unusually short sentences, a kind of mental shorthand, when she is depicting Hugo’s point of view, for example. Humour lurks in the background of every scene. I love her descriptive use of words - "watchdoggery" and "Sir Primrose", for example.
All in all a treat which I have already read twice.
Average customer rating:
|
The Honorable Thief (Signet Regency Romance)
Martha Kirkland Manufacturer: Signet ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0451187210 |
Customer Reviews:
It Was Just One Of Those Days..........2003-01-08
And now Honor, who was, of course, caught red handed by the world's most obnoxious postboy, must claim to be the unconscious gentleman's wife to avoid severe punishment.
But that is only the beginning. When the gentleman awakens and apparently believes Honor's ruse, Honor finds herself in the world's biggest tangle...especially when the gentleman unknowingly begins to steal his "wife's" heart.
Delightful and funny! Another gem by Martha Kirkland...don't miss it.
A book that will steal your heart.......2000-12-06
Average customer rating: |
An Honorable Thief
Andrew J. Forkes , Rew Forkes , and Jascha Kessler Manufacturer: Xlibris Corporation ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: 0738807605 |
Book Description
Andrew J. Forkes, a safecracker during the mob-dominated gangster era of the 30s through the 50s, chronicles his compelling autobiography with descriptive photos--spanning nearly a century--starting at age five with his arrival in America from Hungary. Prison-school educated, Andy takes us from middle America to Hollywood via Las Vegas and back--recalling a life of danger, and deceit, lightened with humor, romance and friendship. He convinces us that there can be honor among some thieves, but has a message for any would-be thief. Don't do it, get a lunch pail.
Average customer rating: |
An Honorable Thief (Harlequin Historical, No. 616)
Anne Gracie Manufacturer: Harlequin ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000OWUEDM |
Average customer rating: |
3 in 1 Giants Omnibus
James P. Hogan Manufacturer: Del Rey ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000OVNFDE |
Average customer rating:
|
Stillness Speaks Inspiration Deck: 50 Inspiration Cards
Eckhart Tolle Manufacturer: New World Library ProductGroup: Book Binding: Cards Similar Items:
ASIN: 1577314662 |
Book Description
Customer Reviews:
Find the Place of Stillness.......2005-08-26
Books:
Recommended Books